skip to content

  • Date: 2008-08-17
  • Kick-off: 16:00
  • Attendance: 75512
  • Referee: Riley, M

Live Commentary

90mins

FULL-TIME: MAN UTD 1-1 NEWCASTLE

90mins

Both teams share the spoils at Old Trafford, but it will be the Newcastle fans who are the happier of the two. United are unlikely to win the title playing like this!

90mins

A Nicky Butt foul on Rodrigo Possebon gives Manchester United a final minute free-kick. Rooney takes right footed from the right side but it goes wide. Surely the last kick of the game?

90mins

Both managers are on the touchline as the game draws to a close, but neither side seems to be willing to move forward in search of a winner.

90mins

Evra takes a left footed shot from the edge of the penalty area but it's well wide.

89mins

Wayne Rooney booked for dissent, Mike Riley has obviously been reading his new rule book.

86mins

Sir Alex Ferguson moves to the touchline and is tapping his watch urging his players forward, counterpart Kevin Keegan looks the more relaxed of the two managers.

85mins

James Milner (Newcastle) makes an excellent last ditch tackle to take the ball away from Paul Scholes as he lines up a shot.

83mins

Rooney hits a shot from the left wing, it's a cheeky effort but the ball finds the top of the net and goes for a goal kick.

81mins

Milner takes the free kick from the Wes Brown foul from a good position central to the goal but he sends it high and wide.

80mins

Wes Brown fouls Charles N'Zogbia to earn himself a yellow card.

79mins

Fraizer Campbell replaced by Da Silva Rafael as Sir Alex looks to his youngsters to get a win out of this game.

77mins

Fraizer Campbell booked after a rash challenge on Fabricio Coloccini (Newcastle), a rush of blood to the head from the youngster.

75mins

A Rooney free kick from the left nearly finds Rio Ferdinand but N'Zogbia manages to clear for Newcastle.

74mins

After a brief break while Vidic recieves treatment Rooney takes the corner from the left side, Newcastle clear easily.

72mins

Rooney picks up a loose ball and hits a shot but its deflected for a corner. Flecther takes the resulting corner which see's Vidic hit the underside of the cross bar before Newcastle clear for another corner.

70mins

Neither team able to break the other team down as the game turns into a midfield battle, Man U perhaps shading it but Newcastle are coping well.

66mins

Scholes drills in a shot from outside the box but it flies over the bar, he hasn't been on his best form today

65mins

Martins sends Gutierrez on a run into the Man U half on the break with a sweet through ball but Vidic makes a last ditch tackle to spare the Manchester United blushes.

62mins

Rodrigo Possebon replaces Ryan Giggs due to injury. It's the youngsters debut in the Premier League for Manchester United.

61mins

Danny Guthrie sends in a corner which Martins heads over the Man U bar, he should have done better and looked surprised when the ball came to him.

61mins

Jonas Gutierrez sets up Milner who rifles his shot over the Man U bar.

60mins

Marins hits a sweet strike from the right flank but the ball goes just wide of the left post.

58mins

Jonas Gutierrez (Newcastle) makes a good challenge on Giggs after a Carrick short corner, its ben a good debut thus far from the Argentine and Toon fans should be pleased with his performance.

57mins

Campbells long range effort forces a corner for Man Utd which leads to sustained pressure until the ball eventually goes out of play for a Newcastle goal kick.

56mins

Campbell and Rooney combine to set up Scholes but he's dispossed, Manchester United not looking their best here and Newcastle could fancy a famous win at Old Trafford if they keep it tight.

55mins

Beye floats a free kick into the Man U box but Taylor just can't quite get his head to it.

54mins

Sir Alex Ferguson moves to the touchline for the first time in the match, he'll want more effort from his players if they're to win this game.

52mins

Danny Guthrie hits a wild effort after Milner sets him up, the Toon new boy had enough time to produce a better effort and should be disappointed with that effort.

51mins

Some nice interplay between Giggs and Rooney opens up the Newcastle defence but Giggs final cross isn't good enough and Taylor clears for Newcastle.

50mins

Newcastle corner from the left swung in by James Milner but Van der sar catches comfortably.

49mins

Nicky Butt sends a lovely cross field pass to Martins who finds himself unmarked on the right, he cuts the ball back onto his left foot and has a crack at goal but Van der sar is equal to his effort and makes a routine save.

47mins

Evra floats in a cross from the left after Newcastle fail to close him down, it looks good and is heading towards the head of Vidiic but the Newcastle defence manage to get in his way.

47mins

Giggs sends in a low cross from the left, Taylor blocks and Man U win a corner.

46mins

Rio Ferdinand picks the ball up in defence for Man U and sends a ball down the right flank to Rooney, he tries to cross but its too long and Newcastle pick up possesion.

45mins

Manchester United kick off the second half and hopefully we'll see more of the same with both teams pushing forward and going for the win.

45mins

Halftime at Old Trafford and its all sqaure, both teams have had good chances and there could have been more goals but I don't think either side will be disappointed to go into the interval level.

45mins

The closing minutes of the half have turned a bit sloppy but Wes Brown sends in a wicked cross from the right that Given manages to palm away.

42mins

Giggs with an inswinging free kick from the right hand side, he drills it in but Nicky Butt clears for the Toon.

40mins

Good play from Jonas Gutierrez as he sends a low cross to Martins (Newcastle) but the Nigerian loses his footing and slips over.

35mins

Manchester United starting to take control a bit and force the pace of the game, not too many chances in the last 5 minutes but they are dictating the play.

31mins

Coloccini disposses Rooney on the edge of the Newcastle box, good defending and the argentinean looks sharp despite having a stunted pre-season.

28mins

Damien Duff lauches a free kick into the Manchester United box, they scramble the ball away and the defending champions don't look their best here today.

26mins

Michael Carrick replaced by John O'Shea (Man U), Carrick seems to have picked up a knock.

24mins

Fletcher levels for Manchester United after a driven cross by Giggs. This followed a good build up by Utd who were not deflated by Newcastle's opener.

22mins

Martins heads home to put Newcastle in front after a Guthrie cross from a short corner. The big forward rose powerfully to beat the Manchester United defence.

21mins

Another Newcastle corner, taken short. Milner sends the cross in and Taylor hits a volley but it goes out for another corner.

19mins

A patient build up from Manchester United eventually leads to Flecther sending in a drifting cross, for a second it looks like Giggs is going to get on the end of it but he falls down in the crowd.

18mins

James Milner takes a corner for Newcastle but his cross doesn't beat the first man, not good enough.

16mins

Fletcher lays the ball off to Scholes who's shot produces a smart save from Given.

15mins

Again Newcastle sloppy in possession, this time Fabricio Coloccini hands the ball to Rooney who can't do anything with it. If Newcastle want to get anything out of this game they're going to need to concentrate more than this.

13mins

Nicky Butt hands possession to Manchester United with a wayward pass picked up by Campbell, the youngster plays the ball back in the box where Rooney and then Scholes force fine saves from Given before Newcastle clear.

10mins

The game has started at a good pace with both teams looking to go forward. Man United probably looking the stronger of the two sides but Newcastle have had their share of the ball.

8mins

Penalty shout. Jonas Gutierrez burts through the Man U defence and is pushed off the ball by Vidic. Looked a foul to me, maybe just outside the box, but Mike Riley says no foul.

7mins

Wayne Rooney bursts down the left flank and crosses to Campbell in the centre, his header produces a fantastic save by Given in the Newcastle goal.

4mins

Newcastle have their first attack, Martins makes space and hits a vicious shot from outside the penalty area. It goes wide but should send out a warning to Man U who need to be wary of the Nigerian.

3mins

Fletcher takes a wild shot from 25 yards out but it drifts well wide. Newcastle are not troubled and won't mind Fletcher hitting more like that.

3mins

Manchester United win another free kick, Giggs swings it in from the right hand side but it's easily cleared by the Toon defence.

2mins

Coloccini concedes a free kick for Newcastle just outside the penalty area for a foul on Campbell. Giggs takes the resulting free kick but it goes straight into James Milner.

0mins

Newcastle get us underway here at Old Trafford. Manchester United hand a surprise start to Fraizer Campbell while Newcastle give new boys Fabricio Coloccini and Danny Guthrie their Premier League debuts for the club.

Match Report

Manchester United began the defence of their Premier League title with a disappointing 1-1 draw against Newcastle United at Old Trafford.

Points for the Magpies at Old Trafford are about as rare as the sight of the sun this summer.

Yet the sun shone on United's ground for much of the game and the Geordies picked up their first point at this normally nightmare venue for the first time since January 2004.

United's need for another striker is there for all to see and the absence of Carlos Tevez, due to a family bereavement, highlighted the problem even more.

Youngster Fraizer Campbell worked his socks off alongside Wayne Rooney, but that spark of the unexpected which can light the fire of destruction for visiting teams was missing.

False dawns at Newcastle are almost part of the Tyneside skyline, but manager Kevin Keegan would have been pleased with the performance of the three summer signings making their Premier League debuts.

Fabricio Coloccini produced a sound debut in the centre of defence, while Danny Guthrie was solid in midfield.

But the most impressive of the trio of debutants was Argentinian Jonas Gutierrez, whose dazzling runs caused the Red Devils problems and repeat performances will make him an instant hero at St James' Park.

Newcastle also had two older heads to thank for their excellent performance - goalkeeper Shay Given and striker Obafemi Martins.

Given produced three brilliant saves in the opening 14 minutes to keep the champions at bay.

In the seventh minute, Rooney produced a glorious cross from the left with the outside of his boot.

Campbell powered his way through to the six-yard box to meet it with a bullet header which Given saved thanks to a remarkable headed reflex save.

Seven minutes later, hesitation in the Newcastle defence allowed Rooney to pick up a loose ball from Darren Fletcher's right-wing cross.

Rooney pounced to fire in a shot from 10 yards which Given saved superbly with one hand. Paul Scholes was first to the rebound, only to see Given smother his point blank effort.

Newcastle took the lead after 22 minutes. Guthrie's corner saw Martins out-jump Fletcher in the six-yard box to power in a header which eluded Scholes on the far post on its way into the net.

Newcastle's lead lasted less than two minutes. Patrice Evra fed Ryan Giggs on the left edge of the penalty area and his cross was fired in right footed by Fletcher from six yards on the near post.

United created the better chances in the second half but, apart from a Campbell shot which was well saved by Given and Nemanja Vidic's 73rd minute header from a Fletcher corner which hit the bar, Newcastle looked comfortable and worth their point.

Manchester United

Newcastle United

Corners

66

Fouls

1511

Goal attempts

1811

Shots off target

57

Offsides

00

advertisement

advertisement